Baker refuses to disavow new pipeline capacity

Says all options for meeting energy needs should remain on table


DEFENDING HIS ADMINISTRATION’S COMMITMENT to developing clean energy sources, Gov. Charlie Baker on Thursday responded to activists who are aggressively pressing him to take steps to halt new fossil fuel infrastructure, saying all options should remain on the table and that he doesn’t “take a backseat to anybody” on renewable energy.

“As a general rule our strategy on this stuff has been to make sure we don’t take options off the table,” Baker told reporters when asked about protesters who filled his office lobby Wednesday and returned to Beacon Hill on Thursday. “There are always options and possibilities that are not foreseen, and we shouldn’t be painting ourselves into a corner, especially in a sector like this where the changes are coming fast and furious.”

Baker continued, “I mean if you think about where electric vehicles were five years ago and you think about where electric vehicles are now, and where electric vehicles are going to be five years, or six years or seven years from now, I think the idea of painting ourselves into a one-size-fits-all approach to dealing with any of this stuff doesn’t make any sens

Massachusetts has aggressively pursued energy efficiency measures and is gradually moving toward additional renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind and hydro power, but its carbon-free nuclear power plant in Plymouth is scheduled to close in 2019. The state remains heavily dependent on natural gas, and pipeline and other infrastructure projects necessary to expand capacity continue to rile neighborhoods, energy activists, and policymakers.

About 30 peaceful protesters gathered in Baker’s office lobby Wednesday, urging him to oppose construction of new fossil fuel infrastructure that they say is contributing to climate change, rising sea levels, and more frequent severe weather events. Six protesters who did not leave the office by the end of the day were hit with criminal citations for trespassing on state property and unlawful assembly.

“The police indicated a strong preference to skip the paperwork and hassle on their end of having to cuff us, drag us to jail, process us, and then release us. We agreed to save them that hassle, and us as well, but the legal consequences for us will not differ,” protester Craig Altemose told the News Service.

Susan Donaldson, a protester from Cambridge, said Wednesday that she spent her life working as a doctor to save people but retired two years ago to focus full-time on climate activism because she believes she can affect the lives of people displaced by droughts and flooding.

Climate-related migration, she said, is often one of the causes of war. “The more I read about this the more scared I got,” said Donaldson, adding that she believes Baker is “talking a much better game than he’s acting.”

While activists disagree with Baker on fossil fuel infrastructure, several protesters acknowledged steps the governor has taken to boost clean energy.

Meet the Author
On Thursday, Baker touted the state’s growing footprint in the clean energy sector.

“This administration has been a national leader in continuing to reduce our carbon footprint,” the governor said. “I could just start with the very complicated but hugely important piece of legislation that we spent two years working on to make it possible for Massachusetts to develop what will be the first major offshore wind platform on the East Coast of the United State, and the most significant investment that this Commonwealth and this region – New England – has made in hydroelectric power. We continue to make investments that have made Massachusetts for seven years in a row the most energy-efficient community in the country. We’ve continued to make investments that have made Massachusetts the largest LEED-certified per-capita state in America. I don’t take a backseat to anybody on our commitment to continue to chase renewable sustainable energy and transportation options.”

  • NortheasternEE

    Baker says “I think the idea of painting ourselves into a one-size-fits-all approach to dealing with any of this stuff doesn’t make any sens”. Deval Patrick started us down the path to a clean energy future, and Baker is following in his footsteps. Wind and solar power is classified by ISO-NE as Variable Energy Resources (VER) that need firming from natural gas power plants to stabilize the grid. What the Governor does not understand is that the path to a clean energy future is blocked the laws of Physics and Engineering. As more and more VER is forced on the grid by state and regional mandates, that disrupt the wholesale market of electricity, steady state baseload power from coal and nuclear are pushed into early retirement. There isn’t a pipeline big enough to supply New England with Pennsylvania Natural Gas to keep the lights on in the face of volatile power from offshore wind and leftover hydro power from Quebec.

    The Governor’s plan is replacing dependable home based power from coal and nuclear with locally stored fuel to avoid disruptive shortages, with natural gas power with just-in-time fuel all the way from Pennsylvania, supplemented by left-over hydro power from Quebec and VER from offshore. Instead of the promised diversified power, we are headed for complete dependence on a single piped in fuel all the way from Pennsylvania.

    When done, rates, already too high due to the state RPS mandates, will skyrocket. As long as Natural Gas is the primary fuel for electricity, carbon emissions cannot be avoided. and electric cars will be fueled primarily by dirty natural gas.

    Tell Beacon Hill to STPOP! Germany, Australia, and even Denmark are pulling back. In the real world, there is no clear path to the mythical clean energy future.

  • ThisOldMan

    Fossil fuels are going to die sooner or later (hint: google “EROI”), but fossil politicians will need to be shown the door.

    • NortheasternEE

      When the EROI for fossil fuel disappears, fossil fuel executives and their political friends will be the first to jump to other resources. They will not need any help from clean energy zealots to find the door.