Despite virus, business as usual at immigration courts
‘It’s a real public health issue,’ says one attorney
IMMIGRATION COURTS are full of people, often pressed together in tight quarters. But the Executive Office of Immigration Review, which runs all immigration courts, has refused to shut down courtrooms nationwide, or develop a mitigation strategy to stem the spread of COVID-19.
In Massachusetts, immigration attorneys and their clients are very concerned. Some, like East Boston attorney Matt Cameron, have already begin limiting contact with others in hopes of not getting or spreading the virus. But one thing he can’t avoid is walking into court.
“It’s terrifying,” he said, saying the last time he went to court was Tuesday. “So many people are packed in. It’s a real public health issue. And then you’re concentrating everyone from all over New England and sending them home.”
The Boston court services immigrants from Vermont, Maine, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island, some of which have had positive coronavirus cases.
Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Ed Markey sent a letter to the Department of Justice expressing concern about hygiene posters being taken down at one court, demanding that signs about coronavirus be posted around the courts in English and Spanish.
Nader believes that court hearings should be suspended, at least for those who aren’t detained. For those that are detained, it’s possible to do video conferences to move cases along, as immigration courts did during the government shutdown last year.
Cameron thinks all immigration court hearings should be suspended for six months.
Cambridge attorney Susan Church says that “immigration courts look like Petri dishes for viruses, filled to the brim with people who likely lack adequate health care options and shy away from government assistance due to fear caused by this administration.”
A spokesman for the Office of Immigration Review said that the agency is “aware of concerns raised regarding the ongoing coronavirus situation” and working with the White House Coronavirus Task Force and Centers for Disease Control to monitor the situation. It has only shut down one court in Seattle, a city that has seen a great number of COVID-19 cases.
While this could change, the spokesman said, there is no plan for any mass closure of immigration courts. “As concerns are raised, we will address them on a case-by-case basis as necessary and appropriate,” he said, adding that anyone who enters Boston’s immigration court is urged to follow CDC guidelines for hygiene.The union representing immigration judges is concerned. In a March 12 letter to the Justice Department, the National Association for Immigration Judges called for the immediate suspension of all non-detained master calendar hearings to protect public safety. That letter was the second sent by the union after a first elicited no response.
Federal jury trials in Worcester, Springfield, and Boston have been postponed for six weeks to stem the spread of coronavirus. The restrictions will continue “until it is determined to be safe to remove them,” US District Court Chief Judge F. Dennis Saylor wrote in his order.