Lelling goes off on sanctuary city movement
Says what ICE does should be ‘utterly uncontroversial’
A week after President Trump lashed out at sanctuary cities in his State of the Union speech and days after Attorney General William Barr launched a legal offensive against them, US Attorney Andrew Lelling of Massachusetts weighed in locally, calling the sanctuary city movement a “genuine and persistent threat to our communities and the rule of law.”
In an op-ed in the Boston Herald, Lelling said Immigration and Customs Enforcement “is not randomly plucking people off the streets; it is prioritizing the arrest of those who (a) knowingly entered the United States illegally and (b) are now engaged in other criminal activity, are gang-affiliated, or bear some other indicator that they are a risk to the public.”
Lelling said ICE made 2,469 civil arrests in fiscal 2019, and 90 percent of those who were arrested had prior criminal convictions or arrests on criminal charges. “This should be utterly uncontroversial,” Lelling said. “In fact, it should be applauded.”
But Lelling said all too often municipalities direct local police officers not to cooperate with ICE; there is also the Safe Communities Act that is still alive on Beacon Hill that would limit communications and cooperation between local law enforcement officials and ICE.
But Lelling indicated sanctuary measures, like those in Boston, run counter to the rule of law and endanger public safety. He cited a case from 2017 where a Dominican named Luis Baez, who had previously been deported for drug and gun crimes, returned to the United States and allegedly raped a Boston College student while working as an Uber driver under an alias. Middlesex County prosecutors, aware of his immigrant status, sought $100,000 bail and GPS monitoring to make sure he showed up in court.
Despite that knowledge, Newton District Court Judge Mary Beth Heffernan granted Baez $2,500 cash bail. “No one notified ICE,” Lelling said. “He fled the country, and that young woman has yet to see justice done.Lelling accused sanctuary city supporters of selectively deciding which laws to enforce. He said it’s no different from Second Amendment backers who are preemptively refusing to abide by gun control laws. “This is the future this movement has created: local officials, basking in their own self-righteousness, deciding simply not to follow laws they personally opposed.”
Lelling, one of the Boston Globe’s Bostonians of the year in 2019, did not mention in his op-ed his prosecution of another Newton district court judge, Shelley Richmond Joseph, who is accused of obstruction of justice for allegedly helped an undocumented immigrant evade an ICE agent at her courthouse. That case is still pending.