Is Charlie Baker really a Republican?
Lyons, Walsh square off over governor’s political machinations
GOV. CHARLIE BAKER has an R next to his name, but many Republicans don’t think it belongs there.
Ed Lyons, a Republican activist who is a big fan of Baker, said the governor’s acceptance of the grand bargain in the recently completed legislative session disturbed many in the GOP. The grand bargain embraced legislation raising the hourly minimum wage to $15 and mandating paid medical and family leave as a way to take ballot questions off the table that would have accomplished both actions more quickly and would also have cut the sales tax to 5 percent.
“They are worried. A lot of Republicans are losing faith in the Republican character of our governor,” Lyons said on CommonWealth’s Codcast. “Charlie Baker doesn’t sound like the Republicans they’re seeing on Fox News.”
Lyons said some Republicans would like to see Baker go to war with the Democrat-controlled Legislature and fight for more conservative causes. He, however, says Baker’s strength is in choosing which battles to fight and framing issues differently than a Democrat would.
“The most radical thing Baker did with the MBTA was to see it as an organization of thousands of people, instead of a set of infrastructure liabilities, which is how progressives always frame the MBTA conversation,” Lyons said in an op-ed for CommonWealth. “He believed better management and more leverage with labor unions over costs and processes would be better long-term investments than new revenue.”
John Walsh, a former chairman of the state Democratic Party, holds a very different view of Baker. While most elected Democratic officials speak highly of Baker, Walsh trashes the governor for his failure to address many of the major issues facing the state, including the T, road congestion, education, and health care. “I don’t think he’s driving any agenda,” Walsh said on the Codcast.
Walsh thinks Baker is vulnerable politically because he’s too busy straddling political fault lines. He said the Republican base in Massachusetts doesn’t like him. “The energy in the party is in opposition to Charlie Baker,” Walsh said, an allusion to the state party convention in April where, despite the governor’s support for cutting the sales tax and imposing the death penalty on cop killers, 27.5 percent of the delegates backed Scott Lively, a pro-life pastor who is a big supporter of President Trump. (The Massachusetts Republican Party has tried to ignore Lively, going so far as to not include him in a recent Facebook poll of candidates for governor.)
Walsh also said Baker’s support among Democrats and independents is thin and fragile, noting the governor has never taken a stand on anything, except for expanding charter schools, a policy that was shot down by voters in 2016. Walsh said the partisan Charlie Baker that delegates saw at the Republican convention is the real Charlie Baker.
“He’s not a half-assed Democrat,” Walsh said of Baker. “He’s a Republican who’s just sitting and waiting and he has no agenda other than no new taxes.”