‘Frequent flyers’ account for 9.4% of ER visits

As state policymakers seek ways to slow the growth in health care costs and improve access to care, a new report by the Center for Health Information and Analysis on emergency department usage highlights some areas policymakers may want to look at.

The report, released Thursday, is the health policy agency’s first statewide report on how emergency rooms are being used. It analyzes data from 2016 through 2019, before the COVID pandemic. CHIA executive director Ray Campbell said it is meant to provide a baseline for government, health care providers, researchers, and insurers to better understand how the emergency room is being used.

The report itself did not draw any policy conclusions, but the data presented points to some areas of concern.

It has frequently been reported that a small number of health care consumers make up a large portion of health care costs, and that appears to be true with emergency department visits as well. The report found that so-called “frequent flyers” – people who use the emergency room more than 10 times in one year – accounted for 1.2 percent of patients but 9.4 percent of visits. People with Medicaid and Medicare – the poor and the elderly – were much more likely to be frequent utilizers than people who have commercial insurance. These frequent patients are disproportionately Black, and a large number of them are middle-aged (age 45 to 65). Geographically, those in Western Massachusetts were most likely to be frequent emergency department visitors.

The CHIA report did not discuss the health characteristics of these patients. Previous research has found that many frequent users tend to have chronic conditions – raising the question of whether it is possible to provide better maintenance care so they do not end up in the emergency department. Many of these individuals may struggle with mental health or substance use problems, national studies have found  – again raising questions about whether improvement in the availability of mental health care or addiction treatment in the community could prevent some emergency department visits.

Another finding in the report emphasized another long-standing problem: the lack of behavioral health care that is available when someone checks into an emergency room. CommonWealth previously reported that boarding – spending days or weeks in the emergency department – has become a huge problem for children in mental health crisis during the pandemic, largely because of a lack of inpatient beds. But boarding was a long-standing problem even before the pandemic, for children and adults.

The CHIA report did not look at the issue of inpatient transfers, but it did examine the length of emergency department stays for patients who were treated then released. It found that patients who presented at the emergency room with a behavioral health condition spent far longer in the department than patients who came with physical conditions.

The average length of stay overall in an emergency room was 4.2 hours. For non-behavioral health conditions, around 30 percent of patients spent more than four hours in the emergency room. For behavioral health patients (including both mental illness and substance use disorders), 65 percent of patients spent more than four hours there.

The longest type of visit for a non-behavioral health visit was people who presented with abdominal pain, who typically stayed for 4.8 hours. On the behavioral health side, a patient with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder stayed in the emergency department for, on average, 20 hours. Someone who tried to harm or kill themselves stayed for 19.2 hours. The numbers were also high for those with bipolar and related disorders (18.6 hours) and depressive disorders (15.1 hours).

Senate President Karen Spilka has said she intends to make improving mental health care a priority in the Senate this session. House Speaker Ron Mariano said this week that he “is anxious to work with the Senate president to continue to improve the mental health treatment that we so dearly need in this commonwealth.” 

SHIRA SCHOENBERG

FROM COMMONWEALTH

Casino wars: Rhode Island is taking aim at Massachusetts in the battle for gambling patrons, as a new state law prompts casino operator Bally’s to invest $100 million in expanding and sprucing up its operations. Bally’s broke ground on a major expansion at its Lincoln casino Thursday, and the governor, the House speaker, and Senate president showed up to celebrate.

— In Massachusetts, lawmakers representing areas near the Plainridge Park Casino, which is 15 miles away from the Bally’s facility, are fearing the worst and pushing for legislation that would allow Plainridge to add table games and more slot machines. It could be the start of a casino arms race. Read more.

Vaccine passes: Gov. Charlie Baker is investigating how to verify people have been vaccinated, but he stops short of saying he will deploy such a system. Read more.

OPINION

Where are we on evictions: Stefanie Coxe of the Regional Housing Network and Chris Norris of Metro Housing/Boston refute six myths about emergency rental assistance. Read more.

 

FROM AROUND THE WEB

 

BEACON HILL

State agencies spent $4.8 billion in 2020, but less than $25 million went to Black and Hispanic-owned firms. (GBH)

State government managers will get some extra money in their paychecks the next two weeks to give them pay raises retroactively, which Baker officials attribute to negotiations on union contracts which will raise pay for unionized workers. (Boston Herald)

MUNICIPAL MATTERS  

Boston rent prices have come roaring back in the wake of a pandemic that has lessened but not ended. (WBUR)

The Hadley Select Board voted May 12 to not deny people access to town property or events based on vaccine status and not require town officials to be vaccinated. Attorney General Maura Healey’s office is ordering the board to retake the vote because it violated the Open Meeting Law by vaguely describing the planned action as a “COVID-19 update” in its agenda for the meeting. (Daily Hampshire Gazette)

HEALTH/HEALTH CARE

The Globe profiles Dr. Davis Brown, the new president of Massachusetts General Hospital. 

WASHINGTON/NATIONAL/INTERNATIONAL

Rep. Anthony Gonzales, a Republican from Ohio who voted to impeach Donald Trump, says he will not run for relection. He was expected to face a Trump supporter in the Republican primary if he did run. (New York Times)

ELECTIONS

WBUR and the Boston Globe do a breakdown of voting in the preliminary mayoral election, showing divisions in the city and areas where the two candidates in the final — Michelle Wu and Annissa Essaibi George — need to focus on. 

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

Secretary Bill Galvin fines MassMutual $4 million for failing to supervise an employee who went online as “Roaring Kitty” to pump up GameStop stock. (MassLive)

EDUCATION

UMass Amherst received a record-breaking $21.5 million gift to its College of Nursing. (Daily Hampshire Gazette)

A new charter school proposed for the Fall River/New Bedford area will let low-income students take up to two years of college credits during high school. (Standard-Times)

MassLive posts a list of the districts with the highest teacher retention rates, and takes an in-depth look at how one of those districts, in Lee, achieved it. 

The US Department of Education will review New Bedford’s reporting of student arrest data. (New Bedford Light)

Minority students are disciplined at higher rates than white students on Cape Cod, across Massachusett, and much of the country. (Cape Cod Times)

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS

The Massachusetts Parole Board recommends commuting a prisoner’s life sentence. (WBUR)

MEDIA

The Federal Election Commission rules Twitter acted lawfully in restricting access to a New York Post article on Hunter Biden. (CNBC)