In Boston redistricting, battle lines form over district lines 

DEPENDING ON WHO you ask, the Boston city council redistricting process is either moving ahead sensibly toward a reasonable resolution or a train wreck that is unnecessarily slicing up neighborhoods into new districts and creating tension where it’s not needed. 

Such are the divergent views of a body that has been riven with conflict over everything but the wisdom of a hefty pay raise for its members, an issue on which the 13 members stood unified – but must now grapple with a response to a mayoral veto. 

Every 10 years the council must redraw lines for its nine district-based seats. After considering population changes reflected in the decennial US Census, it’s often a matter of shifting a precinct or two here or there to rejigger the map in a way to have districts of roughly similar sized population, as required by law. 

The current round of redistricting, however, requires more than slight tinkering around the edges. Because of booming development in the Seaport area as well as the Lower End section of South Boston around the Broadway MBTA Station, the population of City Councilor Ed Flynn’s district has ballooned to more than 14,000 residents over the target of 75,000 people per district. Meanwhile, the adjacent District 3, represented by Dorchester’s Frank Baker, has lost population and is about 6,500 people short of the target size. 

No small-scale tinkering will shed Flynn’s District 2 of that number of residents or add the needed new precincts into Baker’s District 3. 

What’s emerged, though, is a cartographic mishmash of maps, with at least five proposals now on the table. 

Added to the mix is tension on the council over the fact that City Councilor Ricardo Arroyo was bounced from his chairmanship of the redistricting committee by council president Ed Flynn when decades-old allegations of sexual assault emerged during Arroyo’s September primary run for Suffolk district attorney. (Arroyo, who lost the primary, denied the allegations.) The council is facing an early November deadline to approve the new boundaries a year before the 2023 municipal election. 

Baker said the process is becoming “a sideshow,” with the succession of new maps being dropped. He decried the fact that councilors aren’t trying to work together in an open meeting to craft new district boundaries.  

Arroyo unveiled a plan on Tuesday dubbed the “unity map” together with City Councilor Liz Breadon, who was tapped by Flynn to helm the redistricting committee, the local NAACP, and other community groups. He called it a “compromise map” based on listening to what councilors all said. 

One of its biggest changes is in refashioning Baker’s district and the adjacent District 4, which also covers a big swath of Dorchester and Mattapan. Since the advent in 1983 of the current council system of four at-large seats and nine district seats, the two districts have largely divided up Dorchester between east and west. That has largely also aligned with the neighborhood’s racial demographics, with predominantly white neighborhoods along its eastern corridor on the coast and Black neighborhoods running its length more inland, to the west. District 3 has had three white councilors, including Baker, over those nearly four decades, while District 4 has elected three Black councilors. 

The plan Arroyo and Breadon unveiled would divide the neighborhood between its northern sections, which would be in Baker’s District 3, and the southern precincts, which would go in District 4, currently represented by Brian Worrell. 

In decrying an earlier map proposed by Arroyo, that would have had his district stretch all the way to Copley Square, Baker insisted that district lines respect “parish boundaries.” That nod to a time when heavily Catholic Dorchester neighborhoods were often identified by parish drew a sharp rebuke from the community paper in the neighborhood. In an editorial, the Dorchester Reporter said “the parish dynamic has no place in a present-day discussion about political redistricting,” noting that Dorchester is now a “multicultural stew” and most residents are not Catholic churchgoers. 

The new map Arroyo and Breadon unveiled would keep parishes together – but it would shift several of those in the southeast part of Dorchester that Baker now represents into Worrell’s District 4. 

Baker isn’t moved. He said Breadon “looked totally bullied out there today” after she and Arroyo gathered with advocate groups on City Hall Plaza to present the new plan.

Breadon didn’t return a call on Tuesday. 

Baker has a map of his own that will be presented today, and said the current broad configuration of districts makes sense, with his district including all the neighborhoods along the “spine” formed by Dorchester Avenue, which share common concerns on transportation issues. 

Former city councilor Larry DiCara said there is always one time-honored principle at work in redistricting. “It’s the age-old game of cover my tuchus,” he said. “Everyone wants a district that makes it easier to get reelected.” 

MICHAEL JONAS

 

NEW STORIES FROM COMMONWEALTH MAGAZINE

 

Broadening the audience: With the recent run of Twilight: Los Angeles, 1992 by playwright Anna Deavere Smith, the American Repertory Theater in Cambridge tried to broaden the audience exposed to the play’s racial issues by offering free or reduced-price tickets, primarily to high school students. Read more.

How to fix the T: Three panels of experts and advocates brought together by the MBTA Advisory Board examine what went wrong at the MBTA and how to fix it. CommonWealth uses a Q&A explainer to sift through the information. Read more.

Ludlow solar field: The state’s largest solar field opens in Ludlow, with its electricity flowing to municipal light plants. Read more.

OPINION

Colorblind Constitution: Author Jeffrey Boutwell examines Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson’s stand against a “colorblind” Constitution. Read more.

 

STORIES FROM ELSEWHERE AROUND THE WEB

 

MUNICIPAL MATTERS  

Boston has one trailer park. Is it the answer to the high cost of housing? (GBH)

By four votes, Orleans approves a partial ban on fertilizers. (Cape Cod Times)

HEALTH/HEALTH CARE

Boston University says it complied with all regulatory rules in its recent research that combined different COVID strains. (Boston Herald) BU says a British tabloid sensationalized findings from the research. Federal officials say they’re looking at whether the university should have shared more details of the research with them. (Boston Globe

ELECTIONS

New polling shows Maura Healey with a commanding lead over Geoff Diehl in the race for governor. Democrats lead in contests for the other statewide offices as well. Diana DiZoglio’s lead over Republican Anthony Amore in the race for auditor – billed as the GOP’s best hope for a statewide win – is smaller than that of Democrats in other contests, but still a sizable 15 point margin. (Boston Globe

US Rep. Seth Moulton says he won’t debate his Republican opponent Robert May because May denied the result of the 2020 presidential election. (Salem News)

Retail liquor giant Total Wine is jumping into the fray on Question 3 to oppose the ballot question backed by independent liquor stores that loosen the cap on liquor store licenses but set a lower limit on all-alcohol licenses. (Boston Globe)

Nearly two-thirds of legislative races are uncontested in the general election. (Salem News)

Howie Carr offers a voter guide for the November election, which consists of urging votes for Republican candidates – where they appear on the ballot – and voting down Question 1 and Question 4, the millionaires surtax and driver’s licenses for undocumented immigrants. (Boston Herald

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

Employers will be forced to pay nearly $2 billion to repay loans the state took out to cover enhanced unemployment benefits during the pandemic. (Gloucester Daily Times)

General Electric, which announced to great fanfare it was relocating its headquarters to Boston in 2016, is quietly shutting down the headquarters. (Boston Globe

Many seniors on the South Coast are struggling due to increasing rents and high housing costs. (Standard-Times)

Premium pay for working Sundays and holidays is set to be phased out by January 1, 2023. (MassLive)

A Tax Expenditure Review Commission flags some tax breaks for potential elimination. (Eagle-Tribune)

EDUCATION

School is canceled for a third day in Haverhill amid a teachers’ strike. (Eagle-Tribune)

Construction is underway on a $30 million renovation project in Quincy that will turn an old office building and factory into a special education school. (Patriot Ledger)

Assumption University selected Greg Weiner, a Jewish author and former political consultant, as the first non-Catholic president in the history of the school, which was founded in 1904. (Boston Globe)  

TRANSPORTATION

The continued Orange Line slowdown isn’t just exasperating to commuters. It has the Globe’s transportation reporter, Taylor Dolven, calling out T officials for misleading and frequently changing explanations for what’s going on. (Boston Globe

The Pioneer Valley Transit Authority gets $67.5 million to continue electrifying its bus fleet. (MassLive)

ENERGY/ENVIRONMENT

The CEO of Trustees of Reservations, John Judge, will depart after just eight months on the job, an exit being attributed to differences in “visions and approach” with the organization’s board. (Boston Globe)  

Hydro-Quebec, the provincially owned utility of Quebec acquires the largest conventional hydroelectricity producer in New England. (Daily Hampshire Gazette)

Ecologists are testing whether ribbed mussels can be used to save the state’s salt marshes. (WBUR)

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS

A jury awarded Fred Weichel $33 million for being wrongfully convicted of a 1980 murder, a case in which James “Whitey” Bulger loomed large. (Boston Globe

Burlington lawyer Mark Archer, who ran for Essex County sheriff in 2016, loses his law license for mishandling client funds. (Salem News)

MEDIA

Layoffs at newspapers and news sites tapered off considerably in 2021 compared to 2020. (Nieman Journalism Lab)

PASSINGS

Ryan Kennedy, a Hampden County correctional officer who was recently honored for saving a woman’s life, dies at 36. (MassLive)