Lawmakers walk tightrope on wind power contracts
The Legislature’s energy experts say it makes sense to penalize CommonWealth Wind and Mayflower Wind if they default on their recently approved power purchase contracts, but the lawmakers don’t want the penalties to include a ban on participation in an upcoming offshore wind procurement.
The House and Senate chairs of the Legislature’s Utilities, Telecommunications, and Energy Committee say the state needs to walk a fine line between penalizing the companies but not penalizing itself.
The Department of Public Utilities on December 30 approved power purchase contracts between the state’s three utilities and Commonwealth Wind and Mayflower Wind. Avangrid, the developer behind Commonwealth Wind, said it couldn’t finance its project with the existing terms, and Mayflower, a joint venture of Shell Energy Ventures and Ocean Winds, said it faces a similar predicament.
Appearing on The Codcast, Sen. Michael Barrett of Lexington and Rep. Jeffrey Roy of Franklin said they were sympathetic to the challenges the wind farm developers are facing, including rising inflation and interest rates, supply chain difficulties, and the war in Ukraine.
“The world is a different place,” Barrett said. “The war in Ukraine could not have been anticipated. The impact on natural gas prices in Europe and the attraction of LNG toward Europe and away from New England which relies on LNG [liquefied natural gas] for winter heating could not have been entirely anticipated. Supply chain disruptions are real.”
But Barrett said state policymakers also face a challenge. “On the one hand, you don’t want to let these developers exploit you and cite these recent trends in order to get a better deal. But you also have to acknowledge that some things truly are unprecedented. What I’m interested in is preserving competition for the next round,” he said.
“So even though you’re upset about Mayflower and Avangrid, you could probably find a way forward that looks something like this,” Barrett said. “First of all, you might want to impose a money penalty on Avangrid if it chooses truly to default and step back from performing a contract that they’ve signed. You may want to impose a similar money penalty on Mayflower. That’s separate, though, from deciding whether or not to bar them from competing in the next round. You may want to assess points against their bid in the next round. But, fundamentally, you want to keep as many of these offshore developers in the race as you can.”
Four wind farm developers hold offshore wind leases off the coast of Massachusetts. Only Avangrid and Mayflower have landed contracts so far to build out wind farms in their lease areas, with Orsted and Equinor currently choosing to pursue projects in other lease areas they own off the coast of other states.
Roy said he agrees with Barrett’s analysis. “We don’t need companies making promises they can’t keep, but we do need to get robust renewable energy,” Roy said. “I’m all for moving forward and working with these companies so we can do that and achieve our goal.”
Roy is concerned about losing the economic benefits associated with the Avangrid bid — a cable manufacturing plant at Brayton Point in Somerset and a buildout of the Salem waterfront to accommodate offshore wind – but he predicts these investments will happen eventually because they are needed to service the emerging offshore wind industry.
“If Avangrid doesn’t proceed with its project, there’s going to be another company behind them that will do it,” he said.
Roy and Barrett touched on a number of other topics:
– The Democratic lawmakers don’t expect the state’s energy strategy to change dramatically under Gov. Maura Healey, but they said her appointment of a cabinet-level climate chief signals a change in tone.
“I do expect she is going to raise the bar a bit,” Roy said. Barrett said he had some serious policy differences with the Baker administration, and those may ease with Healey. “You are going to see us singing from the same hymn book more often,” he predicted.
– Healey is calling for doubling the state’s wind power target from 5,600 megawatts to 11,200 megawatts. The two lawmakers welcome the higher goal, but say it must be accompanied by a change in the way clean energy is procured.
Barrett would like to see procurements involving multiple states and procurements pitting various types of clean energy – offshore wind, onshore wind, solar, hydro, etc. — against each other to keep pricing competitive.
Both lawmakers like the recent decision by the Baker administration to have Massachusetts ratepayers take a 40 percent stake in a proposed onshore wind farm in Maine. “It’s a great example of regional cooperation,” Roy said.
Roy would also like to see Massachusetts ratepayers take a stake in the Millstone nuclear power plants in Connecticut. “Hopefully with the next administration perhaps that issue can be revisited,” Roy said.
NEW STORIES FROM COMMONWEALTH MAGAZINE
Farmers battered by climate change: Climate change is starting to take a toll on Massachusetts farmers, who are dealing with drought one growing season and excessive rains the next. Read more.
Climate office created: Gov. Maura Healey on Friday signed an executive order establishing a cabinet-level climate office and rounded out her cabinet with a holdover from her predecessor’s cabinet and two temps.
– Terrence Reidy will remain as secretary of public safety and security and Mary Beckman and Mike Doheny will be the interim secretaries of health and human services and labor and workforce development.
The Baker legacy: Steven Kadish, a former chief of staff to Charlie Baker and a coauthor of a book with him, lists five key elements of the former governor’s legacy. Read more.
Medicaid coverage at jails: Middlesex County Sheriff Peter Koutoujian calls for a change in federal law that will allow prisoners at the jail to be covered by Medicaid. Read more.
Stopping the end-arounds: Amy Dain, in the final installment of her series of articles on the MBTA Communities housing law, says the measure is expected to put an end to the seemingly never-ending restrictions on multi-family housing. Read more.
STORIES FROM ELSEWHERE AROUND THE WEB
Gov. Maura Healey opens up about her partner, Joanna Lydgate, an attorney who formerly served as her deputy in the attorney general’s office. (Boston Globe)
Hardwick voters soundly reject plans for a horse breeding, retirement and racing facility at Great Meadowbrook Farm. (Telegram & Gazette)
A group of city and state elected officials from Boston weigh in with a letter to the city opposing a proposal to convert a hotel on Morrissey Boulevard in Dorchester into supportive housing for formerly homeless people. (Boston Herald)
The chair of the Saugus Board of Selectmen says it’s time for the municipality to become a city. (Daily Item)
“Bad timing” is blamed for the breakoff of a proposed merger between UMass Memorial Health and Heywood Healthcare. (Telegram & Gazette)
Some patients in Massachusetts have faced steep bills for the anti-HIV drug PrEP, despite the fact that most insurers are required to cover the treatment at no cost. (Boston Globe)
The state launches an around the clock behavioral health helpline. (GBH)
A new study says gas stoves are responsible for 15 percent of childhood asthma cases in Massachusetts. (Boston Globe)
Hundreds of supporters of Jair Bolsanaro, Brazil’s former right-wing president who was defeated in October, storm government buildings in the capital of Brasilia claiming election fraud in an eerie echo of the January 6, 2021, riots that overtook the US Capitol. (New York Times)
Democrats are calling on House Speaker Ron Mariano to seat Kristin Kassner of South Hamilton, who won her House election by one vote against Republican incumbent Lenny Mirra. Mariano says the election results are undergoing a legislative review. (Salem News)
The conservative-leaning Heritage Foundation questions Massachusetts’ election security. Secretary of the Commonwealth Bill Galvin questions the Heritage Foundation. (Boston University Statehouse Program)
State leaders are advancing plans to offer free community college. (Eagle-Tribune)
With COVID cases rising, UMass Boston imposes an indoor mask mandate. (MassLive)
An Israeli composer’s musical drama, an ode to Ludwig van Beethoven, has its American premiere with the Boston Symphony Orchestra. (GBH)
New England power plants face $39 million in penalty fines for failures during the Christmas Eve storm. (USA Today Network)
The family of a Newton man who was shot and killed by police officers two years ago filed a civil lawsuit against the city in an attempt to draw attention to the way law enforcement responds to mental health emergencies. (WBUR)
Bristol County Sheriff Paul Heroux – who vowed to improve conditions at the jail facilities he oversees – blames a likely “blind spot” in procedures for the apparent suicide of an inmate last Thursday, only days after he took office. (New Bedford Light)
Clodovaldo Conception, a former Springfield city councilor and long-time advocate for the Sixteen Acres neighborhood, dies at 90. (MassLive)