State ed board members rip slow pace of learning recovery targets 

WITH SCHOOLS ACROSS the state grappling to address the learning loss tied to pandemic-related school closures and disruptions, the state education department is working to set goals for student achievement gains over the coming years. 

As state Education Commissioner Jeff Riley framed it at the start of a presentation to the state board of education on Tuesday, the aim is to set “ambitious yet attainable targets.” 

But where those twin goals intersect is a matter of judgment, with several board members expressing strong reservations about the proposed timeline laid out by state education officials, and one even invoking the “separate but equal” language of the Jim Crow era to criticize the much longer timeline outlined for gains by students who suffered the greatest learning loss. 

Associate Commissioner Rob Curtin outlined goals designed to get students back to the achievement levels in math and English seen in 2019, the last year of state testing before the pandemic. He told the board that learning loss varied significantly among student groups, schools, and districts. Dividing schools in quartiles, he said a quarter of the state’s K-8 schools lost 10 or more scaled points on the English MCAS test between 2019 and 2022. “I can’t emphasize enough how big of a decline that is,” he said, calling the decreases that were seen “unprecedented.” The quartile of schools experiencing the smallest losses, on the other hand, included some that actually saw gains in English and math scores between those years. 

“The amount of decline will determine the time to recovery,” Curtin explained. He added that the four-year recovery expectations of those in the lowest quartile are extremely rigorous, given the degree of learning loss they suffered. 

But board members voiced strong concerns that the targets are not nearly ambitious enough for those students who have fallen the furthest behind. 

“I have some real concerns for our kids who have been most affected by the declines in learning acquisition,” said Tricia Canavan, a board member from South Hadley. Referring to the four different timelines set out for learning gain recovery, “the phrase that was in my head was separate but equal,” said Canavan. “I’m not saying this is equivalent to Jim Crow South, but I’m very concerned about having these two parallel tracks for different groups of kids. I would be remiss if I didn’t say that we have to do better.” 

Curtin’s slide presentation to the board used graphics showing airport runways to represent the varying lengths of time proposed for achievement recovery based on how much learning loss a group had experienced. 

Michael Moriarty, a board member from Holyoke, proposed a different metaphor. “Rather than thinking of this with the airline analogy of how long the runway has to be,” he said, maybe what’s needed is “a medical analogy” in which the approach is triage – where resources are focused intently on those with the greatest need. 

Canavan and others pointed to the huge pots of federal relief aid still not spent by districts, urging that the state push for this money to be strategically deployed to fund tutoring and other strategies shown to be effective in remediating learning loss. 

“There’s a whole lot of money that’s just pouring in,” said Matthew Hills, the board vice chair, referring to federal funding. The goals for recovery the department has proposed, he said, are “not going to be success. That’s going to be getting to 2019 levels, which for a whole lot of districts were nothing to write home about.” 

“Setting a return to 2019 achievement levels as our goal is an unambitious, backward-looking, ‘return to the status quo’ standard,” he wrote, “particularly given that was a moment in time when Massachusetts had the dubious distinction of having some of the biggest achievement gaps in the country.”   

MICHAEL JONAS

NEW STORIES FROM COMMONWEALTH MAGAZINE

Stress test for power grid: The New England power grid was put under severe distress over the Christmas holiday as reserve electricity supplies temporarily came up short on December 24 and the fuel mix used to produce electricity over the course of several days shifted from natural gas to oil, which yields more carbon emissions. Read more. 

Baker bids adieu: In a live-streamed address from his office, Gov. Charlie Baker said a brief and straightforward goodbye to Massachusetts residents in a speech that ignored his administration’s shortcomings and touted his accomplishments. “We did it all without partisan bickering,” he said. Read more.

Last-minute appointments by Baker: As he exits state government, Gov. Charlie Baker is making some last-minute appointments to boards and commissions. Among the appointees were two Republican state reps – Shawn Dooley and Timothy Whelan – who lost November races for other offices. Rep. William Straus of Mattapoisett raised concerns about Baker filling vacancies on the MassDOT and MBTA boards just as Democrat Maura Healey is preparing to move into the governor’s office. Read more.

Inaugurations delayed: Speaker Ron Mariano said the House will temporarily delay the inauguration of Democrats Margaret Scarsdale of Pepperell and Kristin Kassner of Hamilton to give a special committee time to review the “last minute legal issues raised in each race.” Scarsdale and Kassner narrowly won their races after recounts, but the results are being challenged in court by their Republican opponents. Current vote totals indicate Kassner edged Rep. Leonard Mirra by one vote and Scarsdale defeated Andrew Shepherd by seven votes. Read more.

OPINION

Solving zoning puzzle: Public policy research consultant Amy Dain, in the second installment of her five-part series on the Massachusetts Communities housing development law, focuses on the meaning of “gross density” of 15 units per acre. Read more.

STORIES FROM ELSEWHERE AROUND THE WEB

BEACON HILL

Gov. Charlie Baker signs into law a transportation bill offering new protections for pedestrians and cyclists. (State House News Service)

Gov. Baker, in an interview with North of Boston Media Group’s Christian Wade, reflects on his accomplishments working with local leaders and spurring an offshore wind industry. 

MUNICIPAL MATTERS  

Lawsuits stemming from a complicated sex scandal involving three Rockland town officials in 2018 have been settled. (Patriot Ledger)

The Boston police worked 1,675 overtime hours during the royal visit by Prince William and Princess Kate of Wales, costing the city more than $105,000. (MassLive)

WASHINGTON/NATIONAL/INTERNATIONAL

House Republicans were unable to elect a speaker after three ballots, with Kevin McCarthy’s effort to secure the post thwarted by a group of more than a dozen hard-right members who held back their votes for him. It marked the first time in 100 years that a speaker wasn’t elected by the majority party on the first ballot at the start of a new session of Congress. (Washington Post) 

The US Food and Drug Administration finalizes rules expanding the availability of abortion pills. (NPR)

ELECTIONS

Auditor-elect Diana DiZoglio announces plans for her inauguration ceremony on January 18 at Methuen High School. (MassLive)

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

Sam Bankman-Fried, the former CEO of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX, pleads not guilty to eight criminal charges. (NPR)

New England’s ski lodges are expanding, after several seasons affected by COVID. (MassLive)

EDUCATION

State teachers’ unions are making a push to repeal the state law banning public employees from going on strike. (Boston Globe) 

Bay State College, a tiny for-profit school in Boston’s Back Bay, is facing big headwinds. (Boston Globe) 

TRANSPORTATION

The MBTA is removing its vaccine mandate for employees – and giving 8 T workers who were fired for refusing shots a chance to return to their jobs. (Boston Herald) 

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS

Incoming Berkshire County District Attorney Timothy Shugrue asked the Ethics Commission if he could hire his wife as his chief of staff, and the agency said no. (Berkshire Eagle)

Boston’s overall crime rate fell 1.5 percent in 2022, but there were 8 more fatal shootings last year than in 2021. Total homicides rose by 1, from 40 in 2021 to 41 last year, though 3 of those ruled homicides in 2021 occurred in a previous year. (Boston Herald) 

Paul Heroux is sworn in as the new sheriff in Bristol County, pledging to focus on the services provided to inmates. (The Herald News)

The POST Commission suspends 15 police officers, including a Worcester officer accused of stealing pay for hours he didn’t work and a Springfield officer accused of assaulting a pregnant woman with a stun gun during an arrest. (MassLive)

MEDIA

In the face of newspaper closures by big corporate chains, three local papers have sprouted in Marblehead. (Boston Globe)