Pay to play on Beacon Hill

The first indictments in the long-simmering scandal over rigged hiring at the state’s Probation Department are in. It’s no surprise that former Probation Commissioner John O’Brien has been brought up on charges — the state courts’ independent investigator, Paul Ware, alleged that O’Brien oversaw “systemic corruption” in staffing probation. But in a twist on the Probation patronage storyline, the indictments mainly focus on O’Brien’s alleged quest to land a job for his wife in the state Lottery, rather than the jobs agency O’Brien allegedly ran for the relatives and campaign donors of State House politicians.

Attorney General Martha Coakley unsealed indictments yesterday against O’Brien and Scott Campbell, the former chief of staff to ex-Treasurer Tim Cahill. According to Coakley, Campbell agreed to hire O’Brien’s wife at the Lottery after O’Brien threw a pair of fundraisers for Cahill’s political committee. The Treasury later hired O’Brien’s daughter.

“Filling a job in exchange for a campaign fundraiser is against the law and undermines the integrity of the hiring process and campaign finance laws,” Coakley said yesterday.

The Globe previously reported that probation employees who “were asked to go [to the Cahill fundraiser] were told it was because of [O’Brien’s] wife and daughter. It was payback.”

O’Brien is being charged with making a false report, bribery, conspiracy to commit campaign finance violations, campaign finance violations, and conspiracy to get a job for his wife by unlawful means. Campbell is charged with conspiracy to commit campaign finance violations, campaign finance violations, conspiracy to get O’Brien’s wife a job by unlawful means, and disguising campaign contributions.

WBUR’s David Boeri calls this the year of political scandal on Beacon Hill. The Herald’s editorial board says Coakley’s warning yesterday — “The investigation is ongoing” — ranks “among the most beautiful words in the English language.” Don’t forget that a pair of grand juries — one in Suffolk County, one at the federal level — are investigating hiring at probation. Or that the federal grand jury is specifically looking into the Legislature’s role in the patronage scandal.

The Patriot Ledger spoke with O’Brien’s attorney, who said the former commissioner is being punished for refusing to testify against politicians. He also contrasts O’Brien’s case to those against Sal DiMasi and Chuck Turner, saying, “There is no envelope. There is no money in a handshake.”

Cahill’s attorney issued a statement saying there’s no evidence of a quid pro quo. But the Herald warns that Cahill clearly appears to be a target in Coakley’s investigation. Adding to the smoke around Cahill: The indictments were previously sealed, meaning that the grand jury was told about the role of one or more unindicted co-conspirators. O’Brien’s attorney, Paul Flavin, said the AG’s office has pressured the former probation commissioner to testify against Beacon Hill politicians. And Coakley’s office is currently looking into Cahill, beyond his office’s connection to O’Brien and probation. In fact, storm clouds have followed Cahill ever since the former state treasurer launched a quixotic third-party run for governor.

During the campaign, Cahill was abandoned by his running mate and his top campaign staff, and faced accusations that he was using publicly-financed Lottery ads to further his gubernatorial ambitions. Cahill’s former running mate even alleged that a top Cahill campaign advisor coordinated negative ad strategies with the campaign of Gov. Deval Patrick.

The allegations about collusion went nowhere. But the Cahill advisor who was allegedly at the forefront of the effort has become ensnared in a federal investigation. The advisor, Neil Morrison, was a former Cahill aide who became a Goldman Sachs bond banker. The Securities and Exchange Commission maintains tight restrictions on bond bankers’ political involvement, to guard against pay-to-play scandals. The SEC is currently investigating whether Morrison broke securities rules when he volunteered for Cahill’s gubernatorial campaign. Goldman fired Morrison for his Cahill ties; the Globe has reported that emails showed Morrison to be active in the Cahill campaign, including doing political work on company time. Cahill has said he is not a target of the SEC probe.

Cahill does appear to be a target of another Coakley investigation — into an election-season Lottery ad blitz. Current state Treasurer Steve Grossman recently fired a Cahill holdover at the Lottery, allegedly because he “inappropriately coached [three] lottery employees to be nonresponsive” to investigators from the AG’s office looking into the Lottery case. Emails obtained by the Globe showed Cahill actively involved in the Lottery ad campaign — a possible violation of state conflict-of-interest law. 

                                                                                                                                                            –PAUL MCMORROW


Gov. Deval Patrick declared this “Car-Free Week” in Massachusetts — and he kicked it off by pulling out of his Milton home in his gas-guzzling SUV even though three Red Line stops are just a half-mile from his house.

Casino licenses would have brought more money into state coffers if they have been legalized in 2007, according to a Cape Cod Times report.

The state must funnel $2.8 million to cities and towns to keep polls open extra hours for the 2012 elections after Auditor Suzanne Bump determined that a state law requiring extended hours is an unfunded mandate.  

The chair of the state Republican Party steps down.


The interim city clerk in Lowell, brought in when the former clerk was arrested on larceny charges, issues a report saying politically connected people received favorable treatment and the office was run poorly, reports the Lowell Sun. Meanwhile, infighting over the clerk’s office boiled over at a city council meeting.

As former Lawrence School Superintendent Wilfredo Laboy prepares to go to trial in November on charges of fraud and embezzlement, his lawyer says he is completely innocent. “Stay tuned,” he tells the Eagle-Tribune.

A federal appeals court reinstated the suit by the family of a Boston man who spent 34 years in prison because, they claim, Boston police framed him for the 1971 murder of his former sister-in-law’s boyfriend. Via Universal Hub.

Quincy Mayor Thomas Koch has promised the School Committee he will present details for construction of a $1 million track at a field near the high school, a divisive issue in the city for more than six years. A Superior Court decision two weeks ago said Koch did not have the authority to unilaterally move forward with the plan.

A New Bedford community activist says the former elementary school being eyed for conversion to low-income housing poses safety threats to children.

The unmanned headquarters of the Marion Fire Department caught fire and incurred some minor damage before firefighters could put it out.


Senior women advisors to President Obama complained of a difficult work environment and felt that top male advisors ignored or dismissed their contributions, according to Confidence Men: Wall Street, Washington and the Education of a President, a new book by journalist Ron Suskind. Suskind talks to Howard Kurtz about his book, and Time analyzes what Suskind’s book is really telling us about the White House.

President Obama wants taxes on the rich to be a key part of any deficit-reduction plan, declaring: “It’s not class warfare. It’s math.” Michael Tomasky, writing in The Daily Beast, calls the GOP’s accusation that Obama is engaging in “class warfare” a sham.

US Rep. Lamar Smith, the House Judiciary Committee chairman, wants to see the Justice Department investigate the failed solar panel manufacturer Solyndra.

An unexpected result of the Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision: Deeper campaign finance disclosure.


The Globe tees up the pluses and minuses of Elizabeth Warren’s Harvard connection. The Washington Post mulls over what her candidacy means for Democratic control of the Senate.

Ralph Nader is scouting for a primary challenger to take on Barack Obama, even as the president tacks to the left and adopts a more confrontational tone. But Slate wonders, can Obama stay angry all the way until Election Day?

The New York Times profiles the man behind Mitt Romney’s campaign makeover.


The family of Roslindale native Mark Bavis, who was killed on United Flight 175 on 9/11, the last holdout to refuse a settlement of litigation or payment from the Victim Compensation Fund established after 9/11 attacks, has agreed to terms of a settlement with United Airlines and its security contractor, the Globe reports.


Two columnists ask, is Netflix doomed?

Westboro-based battery maker Boston-Power will open a new factory — in China.


A $120 million expansion plan is on tap for the Massachusetts College of Art.

Three Harvard professors are among the 22 people who will each be awarded $500,000  MacArthur “genius” grants today: economist Roland Fryer, physicist Markus Greiner, and psychology professor Matthew Nock.

Two Andover High School teachers withdraw as chaperones for a student trip to London after being named in a lawsuit by a student who says she was raped on a previous trip to Austria, Switzerland, and Germany, the Eagle-Tribune reports. The student alleges the teachers failed to properly supervise the trip members; the school is standing behind the teachers. In a letter to the editor, a fellow teacher backs her colleagues.

In an editorial, the Gloucester Times slams the $195,000 salary of the superintendent-director of the North Shore Regional Technical School. “Paying anyone $195,000 to head a school with 450 students doesn’t make sense,” the paper says.


USA Today examines how infections contracted during hospital stays affect patients and push up health care costs.

Federal cuts to HIV/AIDS and other programs will have a disastrous impact on the state, argues the Cape Cod Times.

The White House proposes $320 billion in Medicare and Medicaid cuts over 10 years.


Banning the use of cellphones by truckers may not solve distracted driving since the drivers have so many other electronics in their cabs, says The MetroWest Daily News.


NStar is asking the state for approval to reduce its price for natural gas. Meanwhile, South Shore oil dealers are saying predictions of $4 a gallon by year’s end would be largely a symbolic benchmark since the price is currently around $3.80 a gallon.

A coalition of environmental groups is pressing Gov. Deval Patrick to beef up new regulations for biomass energy facilities, saying they don’t live up to the administration’s promises for reducing greenhouse emissions and maintaining efficiency standards.

The Conservation Law Foundation and the Buzzards Bay Coalition are suing the EPA ,charging that the agency has failed to properly monitor Cape Cod water plans, resulting in elevated nitrogen levels in coastal waters.


PolitiFact, creator of the Truth-o-Meter, is setting its sights on becoming an Associated Press for fact-checking, the Nieman Journalism Lab reports.